Comparable evidence in property valuation
How valuers rank, adjust and weigh comparable sales in England and Wales, with a worked two-bed flat example and the traps in Price Paid and listing data.
A property is worth what a willing buyer would pay a willing seller today. A valuer infers that from what buyers recently paid for similar properties nearby. Those sales are the comparable evidence. The skill is in choosing them, adjusting for the differences, and showing the reasoning so others can check it.
Why comparison dominates residential valuation
Valuers have investment, residual and cost methods, but homes bought to live in suit none of them. What they have, across most of England and Wales, is a deep market of similar units changing hands often, with completed prices published by HM Land Registry since 1995. So the RICS Red Book expects a valuer to have regard to that evidence, and every residential valuation asks the same question: what did the closest comparables sell for, and how does this property differ?
The hierarchy of evidence
The RICS professional standard on comparable evidence, first published in 2019, sorts evidence into three categories, strongest first:
- Direct transactional evidence. Completed sales of near-identical or similar properties with full details. A completed sale beats an agreed one, and an agreed sale beats an asking price, which sits at the bottom of this category and is admitted only with care.
- General market data. Indices, market reports, historic transactions, supply and demand figures. They show where the market is moving and support an adjustment but do not value a specific property.
- Other sources. Sales of other property types or areas, and background data such as interest rates, for context when direct evidence is thin.
Use the highest category available and say why when you go lower.
What makes a comparable close
- Location. Same building, then same street, then same postcode sector. For flats, the same block holds service charge, management and build quality constant.
- Type and tenure. Flat against flat, terrace against terrace, freehold against freehold, long lease against long lease.
- Size. Within about 20% of the subject's floor area, same bedroom count.
- Condition. Refurbished, dated, or in need of work.
- Date. Six months is comfortable in a steady market; over a year needs a time adjustment and a health warning.
The data behind the evidence
- HM Land Registry Price Paid. The Price Paid dataset records sales for value in England and Wales: completion price and date, address, type, new-build flag, freehold or leasehold. No floor area, nothing on condition. Sales appear only once registered, so there is a registration lag of weeks to months, longer for new builds, and the latest two or three months are always incomplete.
- The EPC register. The energy certificate gives total floor area in square metres, the energy rating and an age band. Most homes sold or let since 2008 have one. Assessors measure, they do not survey, so check an odd figure against a floor plan.
- Listings. An asking price is not evidence of value but of the market: stock, time to sell and how far sellers are moving.
- Auction results. A hammer price is a binding contract struck in public on a known date: strong evidence for the kind of stock that sells at auction, weaker for the rest.
Adjusting the evidence
An adjustment estimates what the comparable would have fetched had it matched the subject in one respect. Make them one at a time and write each down. Past 15 to 20% of the price, the comparable is not comparable.
- Time. Bring each sale forward with a local index, a hedonic or repeat-sales series at local authority level rather than a national one. Index up 2% since the sale, multiply by 1.02.
- Size. Convert each time-adjusted price to a rate per square metre and apply it to the subject's area. Rates fall as units grow, so a rate from a 45 m² studio will overvalue a 90 m² flat.
- Condition. A refurbishment usually adds less than it cost. Adjust by what a buyer would pay for the difference, not by the invoice.
- Tenure and lease length. A short lease is worth less and the discount steepens as the term falls. Lease reform is in progress, so check the position at the valuation date before applying a relativity figure.
- Parking, outside space, floor level and aspect. An allocated space, a balcony or garden, a south-facing room and a floor above the ground each move the price by amounts that vary block by block.
- New build. New homes sell at a premium to second-hand equivalents, and the headline price often includes incentives such as a deposit contribution. Price Paid records the headline figure, not the net one.
How many, and how to weight them
Three to six comparables is the working range: fewer and one bad sale drives the answer, more and the weak dilute the strong. Lenders generally expect at least three. Weight by closeness, not equally, and write the weights down. A same-block sale three months old may carry half the weight alone, while a different type four streets away confirms the bracket rather than sets it.
A worked example
The figures are illustrative and rounded. The subject is a two-bed, second-floor flat of 62 m² in a 1990s purpose-built block: fair condition, allocated parking, no balcony, 110 years on the lease. Time adjustments use the local index.
- A, same block, second floor, 60 m². Sold four months ago for £297,000. Plus 1% for time gives £300,000, or £5,000 per m². Same condition, parking and lease. High weight.
- B, same street, newer block, 70 m². Sold ten months ago for £350,000. Plus 2% for time gives £357,000, or £5,100 per m². Deduct 4% for refurbished condition and 2% for a balcony, add 2% because a larger unit carries a lower rate: £4,900 per m². Medium weight.
- C, three streets away, Victorian conversion, 58 m². Sold two months ago for £275,000, or £4,740 per m². Add 3% for no parking: £4,880 per m². A conversion is a different product, handled by weight rather than a number. Low weight.
- D, same block, ground floor, 62 m². Sold fourteen months ago for £255,000. Plus 4% for time gives £265,000, about £4,280 per m², roughly 14% below the rest. The record shows an auction sale with 72 years on the lease. A different asset. Set it aside and say so.
Weighting A at half, B at 30% and C at 20% gives about £4,950 per m², or roughly £307,000 on 62 m². The adjusted evidence brackets that figure, A above and C below. The opinion of value is £305,000, with a valuation range of £295,000 to £315,000. The range is not hedging; it says how far the evidence can be read.
The traps
- Asking prices treated as sales. A listing at £320,000 is a seller's hope until it completes and registers.
- Ignoring registration lag. A quiet last six months in the file usually means sales not yet registered, not a quiet market.
- Mixing leasehold and freehold. Different assets at the same floor area. Within leasehold, check the remaining term on each comparable.
- The developer's own price list. Five plots from one scheme are five readings of one seller's pricing, incentives included, not independent evidence.
- The one outlier. A sale 15% from the rest is a question, not a data point. Look for a short lease, a related-party sale or a forced sale; if none appears, give it little weight and say so.
- Non-market entries. Price Paid flags repossessions, mortgage-identified buy-to-let purchases and transfers to companies in a separate category. A sale of several titles for one sum can also show the whole sum against each address, so watch for repeated prices on one date.
Doing this in MarketCode
MarketCode lays out the evidence for any address in England and Wales: the registered sales for the building and the street with their completion dates, the EPC floor area beside each one, and the area index that brings an older sale forward to today. Listings and auction results sit beside them as market context.
The AI Valuation report, made by the AI Valuer, does the selection and adjustment for one property for £20. It picks the comparables, states each adjustment and its reason, and shows the weight it gave each sale, so a reader can challenge a step, not just a number. It is not a RICS Red Book valuation and says so. A lender or a court will still need a qualified valuer.
To see where a statistical estimate stops and judgement starts, read why an AVM is a prior, not a valuation.
Keep reading: Why an AVM is a prior, not a valuation, Land Registry Price Paid Data, explained and Gross development value: what it is and how to calculate it.
Related guides
- How to read a house price index without fooling yourselfA house price index is not an average price. What a repeat-sales index measures, what the forecast tail means, and why thin areas borrow the national series.
- How to run a development appraisal, step by stepA residual development appraisal tells you what you can pay for a site. The ten steps in order, a worked example for eight houses, and the sensitivities.
- Land Registry Price Paid Data, explainedEvery registered sale in England and Wales since 1995 is public. What the file contains, what it leaves out, why the trailing months are always wrong.